antisocial disorder, being a narcissist, and co-dependency issues. Joe is a narcissist who desperately seeks to fill his emptiness because he craves supply. He thinks about himself as a passionate lover and wants to take away all the problems from his girlfriends life even if it means killing her best friend. Read our. When he would be dealing with From an early age, Joe didnt learn how to develop a positive attachment style due to his abandonment and mistreatment, which led to the development of narcissism, antisocial personality disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder. 'You's' Penn Badgley Says Fans Can't Be Entirely Blamed for Liking Joe You have to choose which one to act on. Despite continuously stalking, occasionally kidnapping and holding people captive, and several times even murdering others, Joe genuinely thinks he is a good guy. Because Joe is a charming character, most people watching the show find themselves rooting for him, even when he is facing the well deserved consequences of his own actions. violating other people in different ways. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. as well as other partner offers and accept our. He has a mindset of telling his victims that he is only there to help them, he Proudly created with Wix.com. All of these traits fit the criteria for someone with psychopathy. character named Joe Goldberg, who was quite extraordinary himself. The Id is described as the "unconscious energy" that strives to satisfy basic sexual and aggressive drives. Date: September 22, 2020, Comparison of Theorists: Joe Goldberg When Natalie kissed Joe and he left and told Love, she was so hurt that she murdered Natalie to keep the Quinn-Goldberg family together. Pop Culture's Problematic Portrayal of Psychopathy., Worrall, Daina. Mullen PE, Path M, Purcell R, Stuart GW. 2. ", They're masters of making "the right first impressions, creating this perception, weaving this little web in which they learn about you and stage their entrance into your life," says Neo. One that truly loved beck and other that just wanted to get his way no matter what. As we get to know more of Joes past, other conditions that arise because of his troubled childhood begin to surface. A few additional symptoms that psychopathy has when compared to ASPD include a lack of guilt, excessive vanity, charisma, and a lack of empathy. For example, when Beck ex-lover, Benji, whom she did not want in her life anymore. His father used to beat his mother and hence Joe ended up killing him. In some ways, Goldberg embodies both conditions because he's constantly violent when he believes a person has wronged him, a common justification people with both illnesses make for their behavior. And as it so happens, we can learn a lot from Joe Goldberg. Joe is not a control freak on the bed and loves his girl to come above him and dominate. A relationship that is abusive or harmful does not have to be physically violent. Beforehand, let us go over some Retrieved September 24, 2020, from psycom/the-perfect-villain- You is a show that focuses on Joe Goldberg. stressful situations due to how he grew up. Joe Goldberg is a Caucasian male in his 30s, who recently moved from New York to Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. We know what he's doing is wrong, so why do we root for him? There is no doubt that Netflixs You series, which depicts the most toxic relationship youre likely to see on television today, is one of the most toxic. Studies have shown a clear link between the development of post-traumatic stress disorder and personality disorders, particularly that of antisocial personality disorder, which is often the result of trauma in adolescence as well as negative or broken attachments. Hatters Friedman notes there's no single mental health condition associated with stalking. Joe devalues his wife, Love, while also gaining his bosss affection in the shows latest season. Joe Goldberg.docx - PSYCHOLOGICAL DISORDER Joe Goldberg- - Course Hero Joe Goldberg is a character in the novel and television series You who has been diagnosed as a narcissist by many readers and viewers. Furthermore, he enjoys reading classic literature, which can be viewed as self-care. And no matter what he's doing to win the heart of his latest obsession, including theft and murder, he sees all of his behavior as justified because it is done to help her and their relationship. In previous seasons, it was easy to see Joe as a psychopath due to his severe obsessions and violence with women, but there is more to Joes mental state than meets the eye. Freud stated, "adult defenses, are related to early childhood experiences" (Burger, 2019), making sense why he acts how he is Furthermore, only some people with narcissistic personality disorder reach the level of malignant narcissism, the most severe form of the condition. As for antisocial behavior, Joe does not have any friends, nor does he make any effort to befriend others, aside from children who he feels obligated to care for. Like 'Twilight' before it, Netflix's 'You''s main character is far from desirable - and yet, numerous fans still adore their every move. "If he was my patient in season 1, sure, he could be diagnosed with antisocial personality disorder, but upon further excavation, his behavior reveals itself as a trauma symptom versus antisocial personality disorder.". The fact that Goldberg comes off as extremely charming from the first time viewers are introduced to him is another reason he could be a narcissist, something that ranges from the full-blown disorder to a personality trait. The fact that both ASPD and psychopathic tendencies can stem from environmental factors also brings us to the rest of our romantic serial killers diagnosis. Since then he thinks of himself as if he is in the world to protect women. It's not like a strep test with 'yes, you have strep,' or 'no, you don't.'". As a result, Lev says that the depiction of Joe throughout You, from the voice-overs that detail his thought-process to the fixation on his latest love object, are "very accurate. These individuals often have a poor understanding of dating rituals as well as a sense of entitlement to a relationship. Ltd. All Rights Reserved, Ariana Grandes Film On Sweetener Tour Has Got Netflix & YouTube Into A Bidding War, Happy Birthday Meghan Markle! 12 Oct 2020 When she is in love, she enjoys stealing from and murdering her victims. And if it comes to saving his a$$, he can kill his girlfriend too. Joe seems to fall into a little of each All rights reserved. People who are severely codependent tend to control their partner or the person they're codependent towards and define themselves primarily in relationship to their partner rather than having their own identity, Insider previously reported. they have gone through, which connects them unconsciously. gentleman when you speak with him, who loves to take care of women. Joe devalues his ex-girlfriends in order to manipulate the narrative. "I know it seems fun and romantic, but it's probably a trainwreck waiting to happen.". While You often accurately depicts stalking, it continues to perpetuate pop culture tropes that instill hope that Joe Goldberg will change in ways that aren't possible for a malignant narcissist in real life. (2020). Season 2 of "You" gets deeper into Goldberg's past and uncovers clues that suggest he actually has an attachment disorder, according to Scott. Later in the season, Goldberg also killed Beck's best friend Peach because he didn't like how Beck and Peach's relationship interfered with his and Beck's relationship. Contests2win.com India Pvt. Joe Goldberg is most likely a killer of the disorganized variety, as opposed to an organized killer. Goldberg "seems to be an amalgam of personality traits at abnormal levels that are constructed to make a good story and create a character that elicits a certain amount of empathy" in viewers, despite the fact he murders people, Rutledge told Insider. "[Goldberg] was attached to someone, his mom, who was unresponsive to his needs, inconsistent, and not a safe person to him," Scott said. a woman, he needs to be overprotected. each theorist has a reasonable point in the development of personalities (Burger, 2019). "adult child" (Whitfield, 1991, pg. She thrives on being innovative and adaptable, as well as looking for new ways to improve her company. According to NCBI (National Center for Biotechnology Information), psychopathy is technically not a psychiatric diagnosis. He hurt his loved ones and others whom he suspected. Although his morals are clearly flawed, Joe Goldberg sticks to them relentlessly. As we see in season 2 and season 3, his troubled childhood and the fact that he was abandoned by his mother seemingly gave Joe severe codependency issues. What Does It Really Mean To Be An Extrovert. But the Our website is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. On one hand, the series' central character, Joe Goldberg (Penn Badgley), is the psychotic architect of his own delusional love story. Its worth paying close attention to what Joes sign indicates about his personality in either case. ISBN-13: 9781337559010. Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. Privacy He loves to satisfy her and feels bad about himself when he fails to do so in his first attempt. Even though he is outright creepy, you cant really spot whats going on in his mind. If you ask him, he is not doing anything wrong and thats why his face doesnt reflect his monstrous side. It can be inferred that because Joe was abandoned by his mother, but continued to hold her in high regard, he developed an unhealthy outlook on love and developed toxic codependency. You offers an extreme example of what can happen when a psychopath enters your life. Love Quinn, an unhealthy type of ENFJ personality type, does not belong in this category. Moreover, when he stalks Beck's wealthy friend Peach, who believes he's not good enough for Beck in season 1, or the comedian Henderson, who may have predatory intentions toward underage Ellie in season 2, he becomes the resentful stalker who sees himself as defending the downtrodden against these entitled, underserving individuals. Why Do We Sympathize With Psychopaths Like Joe Goldberg On "You Moreover, Joe's tragic backstory, which includes a mother who abandoned him after he shot and killed her abusive boyfriend and a foster father who locked him in a glass book cage for extended periods of time, establishes the roots of an attachment disorder that make it challenging for Joe to bond with or trust others. Movies, TV shows, and even Joe's beloved books depict men pursuing romance by "accidentally" bumping into their love interest or continuing to pursue her even after she's said she isn't interested. What's Realistic About the Depiction of Stalking in You? Excellent layout, Leadership class , week 3 executive summary, I am doing my essay on the Ted Talk titaled How One Photo Captured a Humanitie Crisis https, School-Plan - School Plan of San Juan Integrated School, SEC-502-RS-Dispositions Self-Assessment Survey T3 (1), Techniques DE Separation ET Analyse EN Biochimi 1. He is also very manipulative and has a lack of empathy. Dr. Nicky applies psychoanalysis in one . Cynthia Vinney, PhD is an expert in media psychology and a published scholar whose work has been published in peer-reviewed psychology journals. Klestzick, Rebecca. Because . The type of person who follows their own cases in the media, as well as who may contact or cause problems with investigators. Attachment disorders typically develop in early childhood when a child has unhealthy or difficult relationships with family due to emotional or physical abuse or neglect, according to the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth-Thomson Learning. And we try to do that for other people, especially if we are very understanding of other people. Even when something goes awry, "if we already had this preconceived notion that this person is sensitive and emotionally present, it's very easy for us to believe they're a good person.". For example, when he continues to pursue Beck and Marienne after they've had a change of heart about him, he becomes the rejected stalker, who seems to believe he can reconcile with both women if he can just make them understand his perspective. would punish Joe by locking him up in a cage below the bookstore in the basement to "teach" Joe Goldberg from You or Dan Humphrey from Gossip Girl are two of the most recognizable characters you may have come across. Joe Goldberg is a character in the novel You, who is a textbook psychopath. For example, when the word psychopath or stalker comes to mind, one would highly likely picture a person with an unlikeable, strange personality who is scruffy, unkept, uneducated, and neither polite nor visually appealing. However, our hero also channels traits that are not covered by this diagnosis. We're immune to trickery, we have good taste in partners, and our BS radars are strong, right? According to the British NHS, someone with ASPD is characterized by being manipulative, deceitful, and reckless. Contents 1 Biography 2 Personality 3 Victims Jung had similar views like Freud did. 40 Comments Please sign inor registerto post comments. He always seems to mirror others, is dishonest, and completely selfish when it comes to his own child. I specialize in borderline personality disorder, eating disorders, schizoaffective disorder, anxiety, depression, and PTSD. Sarah Regan mbg Spirituality & Relationships Editor Joe Goldberg is often described as a psychopath, but this is largely because the term "psychopath" has become a popular tag for the (fictional and real-life) violent killers that grace our screens.The term "sociopath" is also often used interchangeably with "psychopath," but the former, in fact, refers to a person with Anti-Social Personality . moments, they both are similar is stating things come from when we are younger and explains Pop Culture's Problematic Portrayal of Psychopathy. The Owl, bhsowl.org/5097/arts-entertainment/pop-cultures-problematic-portrayal-of-psychopathy/. And above all that, when Joe was civil and asked for a divorce like a normal person, Love decided to paralyse him with poison so he could watch her kill Marienne to save their family. The Complexity of The Psychopathic Mind. The Complexity of the Psychopathic Mind | Danielle Rousseau, 1 Jan. 1967, sites.bu.edu/daniellerousseau/2018/12/18/the-complexity-of-the-psychopathic-mind/. Not as a real person but i rooted for him because of the way he treated beck and how he showered her with "love and Care", I believed he could turn out to be good. To define stalking, it is viewed as an illogical or irrational preoccupation with another individual. Unlike Joe and Love, both serial killers are typically narcissistic, whereas Joe is a textbook example ofYandere, whereas Love is a typical, garden-variety killer. Quinn, his son and newfound friends, which shows us a different side of The first and second seasons plots revolve around the seemingly normal life of the main character, a man named Joe Goldberg, who becomes easily infatuated and develops intense obsessions with women who catch his eye. Henry already had survived, the measles when anti-vaxxer Gil admitted that it came from his children, but Love still bonked him on the head which led to his death. I can really see the thought you have put into this, and your analysis of the show is excellent. 2023 Dotdash Media, Inc. All rights reserved. In fact, codependent individuals can sometimes define themselves based on their relationship, as opposed to having their own identity, which is something we see the protagonist do quite often. In contrast to Joe, a Cancer would be someone who would bring out the best in you. become as dangerous as murdering to help these women out. Protective Services came and sent him to a Group Home for Boys in New York. His work at the CIA garnered three Exceptional Performance Awards. Joe's abusive childhood experiences and flashbacks played a crucial role whenever he hurt or crossed swords with someone he loved. Joe Goldbergs personality type is INFJ, which is the combination of the three functions (introverted Feeling, which is dominant in this type, moderately developed Sensing and judging), which provides him with an unusual perspective on life that he can use to compensate for his introverted intuition. Tell us you love Punkee without telling us you love Punkee. According to Mental Health America, symptoms of codependency include a need to control others and an unhealthy dependence on relationships. of these categories. Become Premium to read the whole document. Love, however, didnt give a single shit about that. personality disorder. 1. Joe undertook therapy sessions, out of which a very significant method used by Sigmund Freud is exhibited in the show. The main couple in Season 3 has a very interesting connection. There are three types of killers: organized killers, medical killers, and disorganized killers. Rejected stalkers want both revenge for the rejection and reconciliation with the person who rejected them, with their inclination toward both impulses changing on a regular basis. Am J Psychiatry. When you are in an abusive relationship, dont be afraid to seek help. Alternative Analysis of the Problem The fact that he has no remorse about killing any of them just shows that he could honestly even kill Paco if he somehow becomes a threat to Joe. worsened as he got older. Retrieved on September 21, 2020 YOU [Video Joseph "Joe" Goldberg is the villainous main protagonist of the Netflix thriller series You, which is based on the novel of the same name by Caroline Kepnes. National Intimate Partner And Sexual Violence Survey (NISVS): 2015 Data Brief. He is a great example of how someone can be diagnosed using psychoanalysis. "He's positioned as alone in the world, abused and neglected by his mom.". In the third season, we see more of Joes background as an abused child, which led to his development of antisocial personality disorder, narcissism and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Rosenbaum KB, Hatters Friedman S. You (the novel and the television series). As a psychologist, what would be your diagnosis of Joe Goldberg - Quora This is a Premium document. We explore Joe Goldberg's personality type, best personality matches, zodiac sign and Enneagram type. While working with Mr. Mooney as a teen, he adopted Joe. His issues also seem to stem a lot from his childhood experiences, which make him obsessively codependent on his partner (or someone he envisions as being his partner), and when things dont work out, the antisocial (ASPD) tendencies kick in. and respect from his mother, which did not work at the end. By: Ayesha Nayak. Fact checkers review articles for factual accuracy, relevance, and timeliness. Sign up for notifications from Insider! Season three of You is unique in that Joe becomes a father, and we get to see more of his childhood and his insecurities in becoming a parent. Looking into the perspective that Freud's structure of Id, Ego, and Superego, we can Get hand-picked resources and highlights from our Mighty community straight to your inbox. Because when we take care of ourselves and our needs first, "that makes us a lot less vulnerable to a love bomber. It'll mean the world. No matter what the opinion, it is clear that Joe Goldberg is a complex character whose actions cannot be easily explained. Still, many viewers seemed to believe he is a psychopath. First off, he was interested in reading and writing, and he showed this off in various jobs and hobbies. is a horrific thing that people have, we always must remember that people have problems like. Even though he is outright creepy, you can't really. There are people willing to assist you in your time of need. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. In the end, A psychoanalytic of Joe Goldberg (You) - Psychology 12 Mind in the Media: How Accurate is The Depiction of Stalking in Netflix's You? In essence, they oversee that Joe Goldberg might switch over these theories. People with narcissistic personality disorder havean inflated sense of self-importanceand lack of empathy for others, which are typically mechanisms used to mask their low self-esteem, according to the Mayo Clinic. Psychoanalysis of "You"'s Joe Goldberg. He is a serial killer, stalker and former bookstore manager who, upon meeting Guinevere Beck at his workplace in New York, starts to develop an extreme, toxic and delusional obsession. Another season 2 scene, when Goldberg says he won't kill Forty even though he hates him because he means so much to Love, further suggests Goldberg has empathy, to an extent. problems daily, especially regarding his narcissistic, antisocial, or serial killer ways. org.lopes.idm.oclc.org/10.1371/journal.pone. Joe, a rare INFJ, has a serious personality problem. Stay up to date with what you want to know. The reward for Joe would be that Benji would be out of Ryan2 years ago what I needed to start mine Students also viewed PSY 255 Trait Theory Short Answer Worksheet The cycle must be identified in order to break free. Joe Goldberg is back with even more toxicity, manipulation and complexity. Psychoanalysis of "You"'s Joe Goldberg - MW Ontario Even though he has been portrayed as an obsessive murderer in previous As a result, it is clear that Joe Goldberg is likely to suffer from antisocial and narcissistic personality disorder. I was honestly truly sad after finishing the series, because I believed Joe could have been a good person. However, his charming demeanor keeps him under the radar even as his body count rises, and Joe Goldberg keeps falling in love again and again. Burger, J. M. (2019). Sorry???? Predatory stalkers are planning to attack their victims and enjoy the sense of power the act of stalking gave them. Some Extremely Baffling Info Has Come To Light About Ellys Time On The Bachelor, 23 Sep 2020 any situation that presents to them. Introduction. 2009 - 2023 MindBodyGreen LLC. That was, of course, until Love caught wind of Joes attention shifting away from her and onto neighbour, Natalie Engler. No one can predict the trajectory of a narcissistic cycle because it is a continuous pattern that does not end or end. present situations, he was flashing back to his childhood memories. Antisocial personality disorder, or psychopathy, is a mental disorder that Joe Goldberg quite evidently struggles with. Many victims believe they are losing their minds, that they are to blame for the abuse, and that they have no hope of recovering. In You, Joe Goldberg exhibits "psychopathic traits and narcissistic traits," says Hatters Friedman. that-romance-built-joe-goldberg-on-you/. found a New York bookstore, Mooney's, as a manager. Goldberg shows signs of antisocial personality disorder, narcissism, and codependency in season 1. Naturally, one would be charmed by Joe Goldberg. style is a defense mechanism intended to ward off feelings of anxiety". You can reach out to the National Domestic Violence Hotline by calling victimconnect.org or the hotline.org. Every Person Joe Goldberg Has Killed In 'You' Seasons 1, 2 And 3 The memes (oh, the memes *spoiler warning*) about You currently littering the internet all seem to have one thing in common: They support main character Joe Goldberg despite his manipulative, violent, and downright psychopathic behavior. One reason it's difficult to pinpoint a single mental health condition for Goldberg is the simple fact "You" was created for television, according to Pamela Rutledge, a social scientist who researches the intersection of media, human behavior, and neuroscience. Joe "I don't wanna kill anymore"Love the whole season #YOUSEASON3 #YouNetflix pic.twitter.com/evUBbbP2HW, Authentiictrash (@LordFranku) October 19, 2021. Kwon, S.-Y. It also makes us a lot wiser in trusting our own gut and our own wisdom," she says. It's easy to see how Joe's pursuit of his love object would fit the definition of an intimacy-seeking stalker given the way he pursues Beck, then Love, then Marienne throughout You's first three seasons. Joe Goldberg: Factors Influencing Stalker Behaviour - Blogger Goldberg's penchant for harming or killing those close to his love interest and obsession Beck also suggest he's morbidly codependent, according to Rutledge. Stalking: What to Do and How to Stay Safe, What's Not Realistic About Joe's Behavior in You, Behind the Keyboard: Spotting Digital Dating Abuse, The Role of Genetics in Narcissistic Personality Disorder, The Signs of Grandiose Narcissism and How to Deal With It, God Complex: What It Means and Why People Have Them, Understanding Bipolar Disorder and Narcissism. While the target of stalking is certainly in danger from the intimacy-seeking stalker, Hatters Friedman adds that if "someone's seen as getting in the way [of the relationship between the stalker and their target], they may be at risk from the stalker [too].". Joe Goldberg has established specific coping methods when it comes to functioning in high On December 26, Netflix released the highly-anticipated second season of its original thriller series "You," which centers around narrator Joe Goldberg, a young man who has a pattern of becoming obsessed with certain women, stalking them, winning them over, and killing anyone around them he believes has wronged his lover. Joe Goldberg - other - COMPARISON OF THEORISTS 1 COMPARISON - StuDocu In fact, Ramani Durvasula, a professor of psychology at California State University, Los Angeles and a licensed clinical psychologist, previously told Insider that extreme charisma is a common red flag that someone could be a narcissist. Klestzick, Rebecca. We rely on the most current and reputable sources, which are cited in the text and listed at the bottom of each article. ", Joe's behavior could even seem romantic "to those of us who have been brought up on Disney and rom-coms practically IV-dripped into our consciousness. Vulnerable narcissists may be more prone to using the cycle of emotional abuse over physical abuse or coercion. She received her bachelor's in broadcasting and mass communication from SUNY Oswego, and lives in Buffalo, New York. What kind of mental illness does Joe Goldberg, the main character of Narcissism varies in severity from person to person. Here, we delve into what scholars and mental health professionals know about stalking to discover just how realistic You is. He also demonstrates characteristics of narcissistic personality disorder, experts say. Joe Goldberg Sophia LeGris Psychoanalytic Theory Freud's theory of personality is made up of 3 major unconscious motives and conflicts, but I would like to turn the focus to one; The Id. Some people who have been diagnosed with antisocial personality raised him, and even taught him an education. gain that love back (Burger, 2019). This is an accurate example of how psychopaths gaslight others. If the whole show gave you a bad case of the creeps, Neo offered some additional advice. Narcissists use their victims as a way to create an illusion in order to fulfill their own fantasies. The Royalty Whos Got The Best Wit & Fashion Sense Of This World. Mind in the Media: What's So Appealing About Oddball Wednesday Addams? You is narrated by Joe Goldbergs ongoing monologues; these solo dialogues are what manipulate streamers into supporting him, and antagonising the characters who attempt sabotaging the stalkers devious plans. He first started in New York and In addition to my work in mental health, I am also a professional book reviewer. Hence, Joe seems to have a form of ASPD (sociopathy), as opposed to him being a complete psychopath. The Perfect Villain That Romance Built: Joe Goldberg on "You" - Psycom 2020). What's the Difference Between a Sociopath and a Narcissist? In the end, no matter how much he loves someone, it seems like he will always choose to save himself no matter what.